Tinubu’s Academic Records: Chicago State University Replies Atiku

Tbe Chicago State University, CSU, in the United States of America, has reacted to the request by former Vice President and presidential candidate of the Peoples Democratic Party, PDP, in the 2023 presidential election, Atiku Abubakar, requesting it to release the academic Records of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu.

The CSU, in a statement sighted by OyoEyeWitness, said that it will release the academic records of President Tinubu if a United States court grants the order.

The institution asked the court to direct “only limited and targeted discovery,” of the information Atiku is seeking, wondering why Tinubu’s academic records “could have any bearing on a 2023 election challenge in a foreign country.”

It argued that some requests Atiku’s application are “clearly inappropriate,” adding that the applicant is also seeking the employment details of one of his former employees.

In its response to Atiku’s request, filed by its lawyer, Michael Hayes, the CSU said, “Finally, in the event the court determines to allow any discovery to proceed here, the university urges the court to direct only limited, targeted discovery on the university.

“As leave to issue any discovery has not yet been granted, and the court’s views on what, if any, discovery is appropriate here under 28 U.S.C. §1782 are not yet known, it is premature for the university to raise objections to the scope of the documents and information sought in Abubakar’s two subpoenas.

“But without limiting further objections, which the university expressly reserves, the university notes that the scope and relevancy of certain of Abubakar’s requests are clearly inappropriate.

“For example, Abubakar’s document subpoena Request No. 5 seeks information on diplomas issued by the university for a 44-year period – 1979 to the present – and Abubakar’s deposition subpoena Topic No. 7 seeks information on the employment status and reasons for the departure of a former employee in the university’s General Counsel’s Office.

“Following this court’s ruling on the application, should any discovery be permitted, the university will meet and confer promptly and in good faith with Abubakar’s counsel to attempt to address all the university’s concerns.”

The USC had earlier deposed in it’s response, titled: ‘Respondent Chicago State University’s Response to Application Pursuant To 28 U.S.C. §1782,’ that “Pursuant to this court’s order, dated August 9, 2023 (Doc 15), Respondent Chicago State University (the “University”), for it’s response to the 28 U.S.C §1782 Application filed herein by Atiku Abubakar (“Abubakar”), States and submits as follows:

“The University Defers to Intervenor Tinubu Concerning Privacy and Relevant Issues.

“Bola Tinubu, the President if Nigeria, graduated from the university in 1979. One of his political opponent, Abubakar, Seeks discovery from the University of Tinubu’s student records and information about the dates and circumstances certain diplomas were issued by the University, asserting such discovery is pertinent to a Nigerian proceeding challenging Tinubu’s election earlier this year.

“The students records Abubakar Seeks from the University via a documents subpoena (Doc 1-1) and the information Abubakar Seeks the University to provide pursuant to a deposition subpoena (Doc 1-2) concern Tinubu’s private educational records. But since Tinubu has intervened to oppose this discovery, the University Defers to Tinubu on the privacy issues implicated by Abubakar’s application.

“Similarly, the University Defers to Tinubu on whether any of the discovery information sought here is appropriate under 28 U.S.C §1782, including whether it is relevant to the pending Nigerian proceeding. The University struggles to understand how – given that Tinubu did not in fact graduate from the University in 1979 – Tinubu’s grades and other students’ records from 1970s and date and signatory information on subsequent issued ceremonial diplomas could possibly have any bearing on a 2023 election challenge in a foreign country. But the University is admittedly not familiar with the issues in the Nigerian proceedings or the evidentiary and other legal principles there in. Accordingly, the University defers to Tinubu – who obviously is familiar with these issues and directly involved in that foreign processing – to advance procedural and relevancy objection to the application.”

Share

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *