Why Tinubu Will Triumph in Supreme Court – ‘Chicago or No Chicago’ | By Adeniyi Olowofela

The controversy surrounding President Bola Tinubu’s Chicago State University (CSU) certificate has stirred social media frenzy, reminiscent of the dispute over his alleged failure to secure 25% of the votes in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) during the Presidential Election Petition Tribunal (PEPT). The latter issue has since been resolved.

In any election dispute brought before a court, the ultimate outcome does not depend on media sensationalism but on the application of the law and sound legal reasoning.

The dispute raised by the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) presidential candidate and former Vice President, Atiku, regarding President Tinubu’s electoral victory, has made its way to the Presidential Election Tribunal, where a favorable ruling was issued in favor of Tinubu.

The matter in question has now been elevated to the Supreme Court for further examination. The role of the Supreme Court is to assess whether the appellate court has handled the matter justly and judiciously.

It is crucial to note that the recent issue concerning CSU’s certificate was not a point of contention during the Presidential Election Petition Tribunal (PEPT) proceedings and is thus not under consideration by the Supreme Court.

Former Vice President Atiku may face challenges in introducing new evidence (“discovery”) at this stage, as the intention may be more to influence public opinion than to seek a legal victory at the Supreme Court.

Forgery is a criminal offense that demands rigorous proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Typically, such cases are initially addressed in lower courts, where witnesses can be summoned and individuals can be cross-examined, as is possible in the Presidential Election Petition Tribunal (PEPT).

Bringing this matter before the Supreme Court at this stage could pose a legal challenge for Atiku’s legal team.

In the legal process, criminal proceedings usually commence at a lower court and may eventually reach the Supreme Court, but the reverse order is not customary.

If Atiku’s case does not succeed in the Supreme Court, and the CSU certificate matter is dismissed, it could have lasting consequences for his ability to pursue this issue in any other court in the future.

Tinubu currently serves as the President of Nigeria, and if the Supreme Court upholds the PEPT’s ruling during his presidency, he cannot be legally pursued on this matter again during his tenure.

Furthermore, presidential tenures are typically four years in the first instance, such as from 2003 to 2007. If Tinubu seeks re-election in 2007, the issue of CSU’s certificate cannot be raised again since he would be running as a sitting president, and the certificate issue would have been legally settled, except in the court of public opinion.

The judgment of the Supreme Court, the highest court in the land, will ultimately determine the fate of ‘Chicago or No Chicago.’

Professor Adeniyi Olowofela, Commissioner representing Oyo State at the Federal Character Commission (FCC) and a Member of the Police Recruitment Board (PRB), writes from Abuja.

Share

One thought on “Why Tinubu Will Triumph in Supreme Court – ‘Chicago or No Chicago’ | By Adeniyi Olowofela”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *